The Democratic
National Alliance has always supported the idea of immigration reform in the
Bahamas. For too long, there has been an undeniable need for real attention to
be paid to the issue of illegal migration and the widespread implications and
challenges it has created for our still developing nation.
On November 1, the
government launched a set of new immigration policies which it hoped would bring
order and clarity to the country’s immigration laws. Unfortunately though, the
government’s efforts have been tainted by allegations of widespread abuse and
mistreatment of immigrants. In fact, it appears that the government’s efforts
to craft a firm and fair immigration policy has instead created a public
relations and human rights nightmare for the Bahamas – a precarious position
considering our economic dependence on Foreign Investment inflows.
The DNA’s position
on immigration has not changed. The laws of the country MUST BE ENFORCED and
those found to be acting in contravention of those laws must face the
consequences. As a member of the global community however, The Bahamas, like
all nations of the world must ensure that any and all efforts to address
illegal migration issues do not cause more harm than good. The government must
ensure that all of its immigration policies are carried out in a way that is
both LEGAL and HUMANE.
In the days
following the launch of the new initiatives, countless stories, photos and
videos of young children being carted away by immigration officers, separated
from their parents and even housed at the detention center have, and continue
to paint the exercise in a negative light; drawing harsh criticisms from both
inside and outside the country. In response, the government has attempted to bring
further clarity to its intentions although so far, public commentary has done
little to squelch the growing tensions. During a press conference on Sunday,
Immigration Minister Fred Mitchell maintained that none the fundamental human
rights of any individual have been violated. However, recent media reports tell
a different story. Allegations of assault on individuals with legal rights to
be in the country, and persons reportedly being illegally detained have caused
even greater concern and now warrant a full investigation as has been promised
by Minister Mitchell.
It must not stop
there however, once completed, the public must be made aware of the outcome of
these investigations and any officer found to be acting outside of the law must
be dealt with appropriately.
Doing so will not
only weed out the bad apples within the ranks, but will also serve as a strong
indicator to both the local and international communities that the Bahamas does
not tolerate law breakers – even if they wear a uniform. For
years, as citizens and leaders of this country, we have chosen to abdicate responsibility for our collective role in allowing this matter to spiral
out of control. For years, we have sold our collective birthright by allowing
the sale of passports, and travel documents, through the bribery of immigration
officials and through the exploitation of immigrants some of whom claim to have
been overcharged for immigration documents, assaulted or otherwise generally
exploited. THIS CANNOT CONTINUE!
As Bahamians it is
important that we support the government and the immigration officers in their
efforts. It must be noted however, that the use of undue and unnecessary force
should not be condoned, or permitted. As has become evident by events on the
world stage; abuses of power by any member of the armed forces could have dire
consequences and could do irreparable damage to our already fragile
communities. Added to the years of alleged systemic corruption which has
existed within the department of immigration, such allegations of blatant human
rights threaten to derail any real hope of bringing some resolution to this
long standing problem.
Conversely, there
have also been reports of immigration officers being attacked and wounded while
attempting to execute their duties. In light of such reports there is clearly a
need for patience. The public is reminded that these officers, as agents of the
law have been constitutionally endowed with certain powers; these powers come
with certain responsibilities which most officers take very seriously. We must
all give them the opportunity to carry out their duties without fear.
Clearly this issue
has become, and will likely remain a hot button issue. As the government
prepares to expand its exercises to include the family islands as well, the
Democratic National Alliance also calls for the government to temper its new
found zeal for the execution of immigration policies with balance. This may require
additional training for immigration officers to deal with the many shades of
gray which now color the country’s immigration spectrum. It may also require a
more effective education and public relations campaign which targets the
country’s international partners in an effort to minimize the damage to the
country’s reputation.
As a country, we can anticipate challenges to our development and
growth. As a sovereign nation, we must however remain firm in our resolve to
protect the rights and liberties of not just our citizenry but of all persons
living within our borders. Doing so will require increased levels of
transparency, equity and an overall commitment to nation building on the part
of ALL Bahamians and Bahamians at heart.
Branville McCartney