From:TheBahamasWeekly.com
Gender Quotas: Do They Work?
By Khyle Quincy Parker, Embassy of The Bahamas
Apr 19, 2011 - 9:39:23 PM
Washington, DC
– As the Bahamas Minister of
State for Labour and Social Development supports discussion of possibly
instituting a gender quota in the Bahamian parliament, the wider hemisphere
continues to wrestle with the efficacy and utility of a system that mandates
greater representation of and by women in the electoral process.
Mrs.
Loretta Butler-Turner was adamant, however, that the under-representation of
women in electoral politics is a matter for the private citizen as well:
political parties cannot run women if no women come forward as potential
candidates. Gender stereotypes and traditional roles must be dealt with if more
women are to be elected to parliaments, and governments cannot be the only
parties to the necessary national debate.
“In
civil society, women have got to become engaged,” Mrs. Turner said.
And
even in instances when women do hold elected office, Minister Butler-Turner
questioned the motivations behind assigning women to what some see as
“soft-core” ministries, rather than admittedly tough assignments.
“We’ve
got to move past that,” Mrs. Turner said.
The
institution of gender quotas was a major theme at the Hemispheric Forum on
women’s leadership held at the Organisation of American States in April.
Participants considered reform of electoral systems around the region, with at
least one prominent Caribbean scholar among those urging for the implementation
of a quota system as part of a systemic overhaul.
More
and more countries are introducing gender quotas for public elections.
According to The Quota Project Global Database of Quotas for Women – a
collaboration of the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral
Assistance, Inter-Parliamentary Union and Stockholm University – fully half of
the countries of the world today use some type of electoral quota for their
parliament.
The www.quotaproject.org/ Quota
Project defines electoral quotasas mandatory or targeted percentages
of women candidates for public elections. Such an electoral quota for women may
be constitutional, legislative or be in the form of a political party quota,
and may apply to the number of women candidates proposed by a party for election,
or may take the form of reserved seats in the legislature.
The
rate at which the number of women in politics is growing is considered too slow
by many observers and participants, and has consequently led to more frequent
and insistent calls for more efficient methods reach what the Quota Project
terms “a gender balance in political institutions.”
Quotas
present one such mechanism.
Women
from around the region were in Washington for the Hemispheric Forum “Women’s
Leadership For A Citizen’s Democracy,”.
Speaking
at the forum organized by the Organisation of American States, the United
Nations and other international agencies, University of the West Indies
lecturer Cynthia Barrow-Giles remarked that universal adult suffrage was
achieved for most of the Caribbean by1951. The Bahamas, she noted, achieved
universal adult suffrage in 1962, and has progressed in women’s participation
in politics since then.
Among
the issues surrounding women’s political participation, Ms. Barrow-Giles,
Senior lecturer in politics at UWI, cited the view that women did not
constitute a political group. She added that campaign financing was a
constraint for women being electoral candidates for political office, and
called for substantial systematic reform.
Ms.
Barrow-Giles recommended that electorate financing be tied to a quota system to
increase women’s political participation.
Quota Activity In The Region
Guyana
has a legislated candidate quota for its parliament: 30 percent of the
candidates for election must be women, or according to the Representation of
the People Act, Section 14 & 17, the list cannot be approved. The law
reads: “If the list does not comply with the quota, the Commission shall notify
this and allow the party to rectify it. Only when deemed correct by the
Commission, can the list be approved.”
While
the quota system in Guyana was applauded in some quarters, it is still a matter
of discussion within Guyana. In March 2011, as Guyana observed the 62nd
Anniversary of Commonwealth Day, University of Guyana Students hosted a debate
competition focusing on whether the quota system has significantly benefited
women in Guyana and other Commonwealth countries.
In
the Dominican Republic, the 1997 Law 275 imposed a 25 percent quota for women
among candidates for elective positions. Post-election negotiations in 1998
resulted in a guarantee that women's representation at the national level would
not be less than 25 percent of the total number of seats for both Houses of
Parliament, independent of electoral classification. In 2000, amendments to the
electoral law increased the quota provision to 33 percent, and included
rank-order rules and sanctions, and a 50 percent quota for the municipal level
was introduced.
Also,
at the party level in the DR, the
HYPERLINK "http://www.prd.org.do/" Dominican
Revolutionary Party (PRD) adopted a 33 percent quota for women on the
electoral lists in 2004, and the Social Christian Reformist Party (PRSC)
adopted a similar quota in 2005.
And
in Trinidad and Tobago, while there is no quota mandated by statute or
constitution, the issue has clearly been a part of the national debate. In
1995, the Women's Political Platform lobbied the political parties to ensure at
least 30 percent women were elected to parliament. In 2000 Independent Senator
Diana Mahabir-Wyatt filed a motion in the Senate calling on the government to
pass legislation to ensure that all political parties be required to select as
many women as men as candidates for national elections. It was unsuccessful.
Hemispheric Considerations
Also
at the meeting, Ana María Yañez, Manuela Ramos Movement Advisor on women’s
political rights, recommended that quotas be put into the constitution of every
country, which will obligate political parties by way of national law. She said
the institution of quotas mandating at least 30 percent representation –
instituted in many Latin American countries – has not yet borne the fruit of
wider gender representation.
Furthermore,
Ms. Yañez mentioned that there were legal issues regarding gender equality,
particularly as the legal requirement of equal treatment could be seen to be
flouted by uneven political representation. Ms. Yañez stressed the need to for
a change in the community mentality towards participation of women in order to
change politics. New paradigms need to be created.
© Copyright 2011 by thebahamasweekly.com -