“In 2010, there were 723 deaths in categories deemed
avoidable in The Bahamas.” This according to recent media reports sourced from the
Sanigest Report – prepared by Sanigest Internacional - a Costa Rican health
care consultancy firm contracted by the Bahamas government to conduct a feasibility
study into the implementation of some form of universal health insurance. The
report also assumed that “ten percent of the estimated deaths are preventable
through NHI.”
Preventable deaths and other modalities are a function
of access, or wealth and diet (which affects the strength of the immune system
and its ability to fight off diseases) responded health minister Dr. Perry
Gomez, and not necessarily a reflection of the quality of health care delivered
through the country’s public health care system.
As far as health infrastructure is concerned, six hundred
and forty-seven more beds are needed to meet standard said the report; since
then a one hundred bed critical care facility was constructed and added to the
inventory of the Public Hospital Authority. Mini hospitals in Abaco, Cat Island
and Exuma are in various stages of completion and additional hospitals for
Grand Bahama and Eleuthera are on the drawing board so it is safe to conclude
that the government is on the right path in addressing the country’s health
care needs.
In a series of headline stories gleaned from the leaked Sanigest
Report, the local media have highlighted for public education, the growing
inequities in our health care delivery system that continue to adversely impact
the poor disproportionately. This revelation further underscores the need for
greater equity through systemic reform as a fundamental component of the social
contract between the government and the people it serves.
For its part, the government of The Bahamas, much like
many governments around the world, has determined that the policy solution to address
this inherent social inequity is National Health Insurance (NHI). The Prime
Minister and the Health Minister are both on record as saying – and I
paraphrase - that in The Bahamas if you are poor, black and you get sick, quite
frankly you die and his government is determined to change this paradigm.
The Prime Minister further said that “it is not if (his
government will implement NHI), but when” and has targeted January 2016 as the
implementation period of the first phase which is a proposed basic benefits
package at a cost of about some $362 million. This phased in approach can
easily take 10 years to be fully implemented at a total cost of over $600
million based on associated logistics and government exigencies. It is
important to note that the government currently spends some $100 million per
annum to insure thousands of public servants and upwards of $10 million per annum
on a drug prescription plan that benefits over 26,000 Bahamians. This is in
addition to expenditure in excess of $180 million per annum to deliver health
care through the Public Hospitals Authority. This roughly $290 million comprise
the existing public resources the Ministry of Health referred to in its press
release earlier this week when it assured the general public that “the majority of the financing will come from existing
resources in the health system.”
The Health Ministry has
revealed that “currently, per capita healthcare spending in The Bahamas is over
$2,300 per year, almost double other countries in the region,” but despite this
high spending, “life expectancy is lower (in The Bahamas) than many including
Barbados, Belize and Grenada.” There must be a shift in this paradigm.
“Universal Health Insurance”
continued the Health Ministry “will focus on improving health outcomes while
also producing annual savings which will reach $160 million in ten years.” This
assertion is supported by empirical data and represents good news not only for
the average Bahamian, but for employers as well who are saddled with the burden
of increased employee health care costs.
The public debate on this critical national public health
issue should continue in order to shape public opinion and properly inform
public policy. The data shared to date make a compelling case for equity and
social justice through the executing mechanism of National Health Insurance
(NHI). The public awaits the considered feedback from relevant stakeholders
coming out of the consultation stage with the government.
About the author: Elcott Coleby is a Deputy Director at the
Bahamas Information Services. He holds a Bachelor of Science degree in
Chemistry (B.Sc) and a Masters of Business Administration (MBA). He provides
frequent commentary on public policy and communicates the works of the
government. Address all comments to the following email:
egcoleby44@gmail.com